What's Hot in Retro Metroidvania? A Deep Dive into Recent HN and Reddit Discussions

Source: Dev.to

If you’re into retro gaming, you’ve probably noticed that metroidvanias are having a moment. From timeless NES classics to beloved SNES titles, these games continue to captivate players decades after their release. But what are gamers actually talking about right now? I dug into recent discussions on Hacker News and Reddit to find out.

Major Themes

Super Metroid’s legendary status

A simple question about what it must have been like to play Super Metroid in 1994 sparked over 1,100 upvotes and 350 + comments on r/retrogaming. People are still in awe of its atmosphere, non‑linear design, and storytelling through environment alone.

Industry loss and legacy

The passing of Shutaro Ida (52), longtime Castlevania developer and Creative Director on Bloodstained, hit the community hard. Ida’s work on Dawn of Sorrow and Bloodstained helped define the modern metroidvania. Tributes poured in from Koji Igarashi and fans worldwide.

Obscure gems getting love

Games like Faxanadu (NES, 1989) and Tomba! (PS1) are having their moment in the sun. These titles showcase how the metroidvania formula evolved before the genre even had a name.

Notable Discussions

• r/retrogaming – “Super Metroid must have been an incredible experience in 1994”

  • Upvotes: 1,124 Comments: 356
  • A love letter to one of gaming’s greatest achievements. Commenters reminisce about the sense of isolation, the thrill of discovering new abilities, and the way the world gradually opens up. It’s not just nostalgia—it’s recognition that Super Metroid set the template for an entire genre.

• Dexerto article (discussed on Hacker News) – “His work on Dawn of Sorrow and Bloodstained arguably defined the modern metroidvania.”

  • Posted: Feb 16 2026
  • Ida’s death after a 1.5‑year battle with cancer prompted reflections on his contributions. If you played Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow or backed Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, you’ve experienced his vision. It’s a reminder that behind these beloved games are real people whose legacies endure.

• r/retrogaming – “Faxanadu!”

  • Upvotes: 284 Comments: 84
  • This 1989 NES title blends side‑scrolling action with RPG elements and non‑linear progression. Its dark‑fantasy aesthetic and unique stair‑climbing mechanics made it ahead of its time. Six years before Symphony of the Night, Faxanadu was quietly doing metroidvania things.

• r/retrogaming – “Games similar to Tomba!”

  • Upvotes: 162 Comments: 95
  • A request for games similar to the PS1 classic revealed a hunger for 2.5D platformers with interactive worlds. Suggestions included Oddworld titles and modern indie metroidvanias. Tomba!’s blend of 2D platforming and early 3D elements still feels fresh today.

• Hacker News – “Optimizing our way through Metroid” (article)

  • Points: 147 Comments: 32
  • For the game‑dev crowd, this technical article explores assembly‑level optimizations and memory tricks used in the original Metroid. It’s a fascinating look at how Nintendo pushed the NES to its limits, showing strong appetite for retro game‑development insights.

Takeaways

• Classics never go out of style. Super Metroid’s continued relevance proves that great design is timeless.
• Community matters. These discussions show that retro gaming isn’t just about playing old games—it’s about shared memories, discovering new (old) titles, and honoring the creators who made them.
• There’s always more to explore. If you’ve played the usual suspects (Super Metroid, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night), consider branching out to Faxanadu, Tomba!, or other obscure gems. Reddit is full of recommendations.

Where to join the conversation: check out the linked Reddit threads and Hacker News posts above, and feel free to share your thoughts on retro metroidvanias in the comments!