Rahsi™ Signal–Enforcement Boundary (SEB™) | Why Device Compliance Is a Signal and Conditional Access Is the Gate

Source: Dev.to

Why Device Compliance Is a Signal and Conditional Access Is the Gate

Most tenants treat device compliance like policy hygiene.
That’s the mistake.

In modern identity‑first security, device compliance is a signal and Conditional Access is the gate. If you don’t wire those two together cleanly, you’re not “managing endpoints”—you’re letting unknown posture drift into your data plane.

This is the Rahsi™ Signal–Enforcement Boundary (SEB™):

Intune Compliance = Signal → Microsoft Entra Conditional Access = Enforcement Gate

When SEB™ is built correctly, a device that drifts (out‑dated OS, rooted/jail‑broken, encryption off, lost contact, risky threat level) doesn’t “become a ticket.”
It becomes non‑compliant, and the gate closes automatically.

The SEB™ Mental Model (Simple, Brutal, Effective)

1. Define the Signal

   Signals are device facts you can trust because they’re evaluated continuously:

   • Minimum OS version
   • Maximum OS version
   • Encryption state
   • Jailbreak/root detection
   • PIN/password posture
   • Threat level (when integrated with a threat‑defense partner)
   • Custom compliance (where built‑in settings don’t cover your requirement)

   Signal rule: If it can’t be measured consistently, it can’t be enforced safely.

2. Define the Enforcement

   Intune can mark a device non‑compliant and run actions.
   But the real gate is Entra Conditional Access:

   • When an Access Control includes “Require device to be marked as compliant”, non‑compliant devices are blocked from corporate resources.

   That’s the boundary.

Intune Compliance Has Two Layers (And Both Matter)

Microsoft Intune compliance is split into:

1. Compliance policy settings (tenant‑wide)
2. Device compliance policies (per‑platform rules you deploy)

That separation is where many environments quietly fail.

Layer 1 – Compliance Policy Settings (Tenant‑Wide “Default Physics”)

Path: Endpoint security → Device compliance → Compliance policy settings

• Mark devices with no compliance policy assigned as – decides what happens to devices that don’t receive a compliance policy.

  Setting	Effect
  Compliant (default)	Devices with no compliance policy are treated as compliant (security feature OFF).
  Not compliant	Devices with no compliance policy are treated as non‑compliant (security feature ON).

  SEB™ recommendation: If you use Conditional Access, set this to Not compliant. Otherwise, “no policy assigned” becomes an unintended bypass lane.

• Compliance status validity period (days) – defines how long a device can go without successfully reporting compliance.

  • Default: 30 days
  • Configurable: 1 – 120 days

  If the device doesn’t report within the validity period, it’s treated as non‑compliant.

  SEB™ recommendation: Treat “lost contact” as a security state, not an admin inconvenience. If a device can’t report, you can’t trust its posture.

Layer 2 – Device Compliance Policies (Per‑Platform “Rules of Entry”)

These are the actual rules devices must meet to be compliant.

• Define platform‑specific requirements (OS version, encryption, jailbreak/root, threat level).
• Trigger actions for non‑compliance.
• Feed compliance state into Conditional Access.

Important reality: Compliance evaluation depends on device check‑in and refresh cycles. Your enforcement works at the speed of your device fleet’s reality.

Actions for Non‑Compliance (SEB™ Escalation Ladder)

Every compliance policy includes “mark device non‑compliant.” You can add more actions, often used as an escalation ladder, such as:

• Send email notifications (immediate and repeated)
• Remotely lock after a time window
• Retire after a time window (admin must then explicitly retire)

SEB™ principle: Don’t jump straight to destruction. Build an escalation ladder that is:

1. Fast signal →
2. Visible to user →
3. Enforced by gate →
4. Cleaned up if ignored

Conditional Access: Where SEB™ Becomes Real

When a device enrolls in Intune, it registers in Microsoft Entra ID. Intune reports compliance status to Entra.

In Conditional Access, set the Access Control:

• ✅ Require device to be marked as compliant

That’s the enforcement gate.

SEB™ warning: If you keep “Mark devices with no compliance policy assigned as = Compliant,” you may accidentally allow devices that never received a compliance policy to pass the gate.

“Quarantined vs Remediated” (What the OS Will Actually Enforce)

• Remediated – the OS forces the user to fix the issue (e.g., setting a PIN on some platforms).
• Quarantined – the OS won’t force it; the device remains non‑compliant, and Conditional Access blocks access.

SEB™ takeaway: You cannot assume the device will self‑heal. For quarantined settings, the gate is the control.

Monitor Compliance Like It’s a Security Dashboard (Because It Is)

Intune includes a Device compliance dashboard to monitor:

• Device compliance posture
• Policy compliance
• Drill‑down by policy and device

SEB™ metric mindset:

• Compliance % is not a vanity metric.
• It’s the measurable health of your enforcement boundary.

SEB™ Implementation Blueprint (Fast Start)

If you want the shortest path to a tenant‑safe SEB™:

1. Set “Mark devices with no compliance policy assigned as” → Not compliant
2. Configure Compliance status validity period to match your risk tolerance
3. Create per‑platform Device compliance policies (Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, Linux as required)
4. Add actions for non‑compliance (notify → lock → retire ladder)
5. Build Entra Conditional Access policies that Require compliant device for key cloud apps
6. Monitor compliance dashboards and treat drift as security work, not help‑desk work

Why SEB™ Matters When the World Is On Fire

(Content to be added – the importance of a robust Signal‑Enforcement Boundary in today’s threat landscape.)

When exploit waves and attack chains move faster than human change control, SEB™ is how you prevent “unknown posture devices” from accessing corporate resources.

*Not by panic.*  
*By architecture.*

Because in a modern tenant:

**Compliance is the signal.**  
**Conditional Access is the gate.**  
**SEB™ is the boundary.**

Read Complete Article