Is it just me, or are AI code reviews getting noisier?

Source: Dev.to

The Issue

I’m hitting a wall.

Yesterday, I spent 15 minutes arguing with an AI agent that insisted my error‑handling logic was redundant. It wasn’t. It was catching a specific edge case the AI didn’t have context for.

I love the speed, but the noise is killing me. It feels like for every 10 lines of code I write, I have to reject five “optimizations” that are actually just stylistic preferences or straight‑up hallucinations.

Why It Matters

• Confidence without correctness – The AI suggests a refactor with the authority of a senior engineer, but when you run it, the build breaks.
• Time sink – Constantly sifting through confident but wrong suggestions slows development and erodes trust in the tool.

Community Prompt

I’m curious—what’s the most confident but wrong suggestion an AI has thrown at you recently?

A Temporary Fix

I got so tired of this that I hacked together a script called CodeProt to auto‑fix these nitpicks. It’s still a WIP but saves me hours.